XII I II III IIII V VI VII VIII IX X XI

Robert Halfon: “Too often, victims of crime in Harlow are treated abominably by the very apparatus meant to protect them, the criminal justice system”

General / Thu 16th Jun 2022 at 08:11am

TOO often, victims of crime are treated abominably by the very apparatus meant to protect them, the criminal justice system writes Robert Halfon in ConservativeHome

Time and time again in my own constituency of Harlow I have seen how the system has failed: domestic abuse survivors let-down, Family Court proceedings flawed, and harassment victims overlooked.

But perhaps most worrying is the fact that in so many cases, sexual assault survivors are not getting the care and support they need. All too often the system will prioritise the rights of the perpetrators over that of their victims.

Never has the above been more true than in a recent case involving a 14-year-old constituent of mine. The Harlow resident was raped by a 13-year-old boy in the autumn of last year. The offender had previously pleaded guilty to sexually assaulting five other girls in Harlow, and has also pleaded guilty to assaulting her.

Pending sentencing, and despite Essex Police and the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) vigorously arguing against it, the judge released him on bail, with a tag. This is despite him living only 120 metres away from his victim and within the vicinity of several schools. The argument being that the perpetrator has nowhere else to stay.

However, my constituent and her family have received no real justification from the courts as to why the perpetrator has been allowed to reside so close to one of his victims.

A couple of months ago the offender was caught in breach of his bail at the top of her road. Despite a call to the police, the boy was not picked up by officers for another week and a half. Moreover, he was then released that very day, with the only bail condition being that he can no longer turn right when leaving his house.

Her mother only found this out, not from the local police or the justice system, but rather when the Centre for Action on Rape and Abuse contacted her.

Just last week, the boy was allegedly in breach of his bail again and was seen by the victim and her mother standing outside her house with no adult in sight. Understandably this terrified my constituent as, chillingly, it could have led to another attack if she had been walking alone to school that day.

Her ordeal has only continued as the bail hearing at Court was adjourned again for the third time until later this month, leaving my constituent once more in limbo. This was due to the fact that the CPS had not ‘downloaded their notes’.

This whole experience has been incredibly traumatising for my constituent and her entire family, as the process has reached no conclusion, with seemingly little compassion from those meant to protect and support her.

What should be happening is that, when victims contact the authorities, empathy should be the standard not the exception.

However, for my constituent and her family it appears that the justice system is operated by a computer programme, which consequently sees victims not as individuals who have suffered and struggled from the abuse inflicted upon them, but rather as numbers to be digitised, receiving formulaic and generic treatment.

I have seen this myself with the numerous letters I have sent to the Justice ministers regarding this case, receiving automated responses which have simply been signed-off by a minister. These civil servant regurgitations are then unhelpfully giving information and organisation links that my constituent knows about already.

My teenage constituent has suffered two major injustices: first, the traumatising sexual assault and rape, and second, being let down by the justice system.

So whilst I do not necessarily blame the ministers who sign these missives, I just cannot understand how there are not proper case reviews or channels which could offer victims a means of true and compassionate resolution after they have endured so much.

My constituent has suffered enough, and I will continue to pursue every avenue available to ensure she receives the proper justice she deserves.

The Conservatives are the party of law and order. But this should not just be about having “20,000 more bobbies on the beat”.

It must go beyond that to make sure that the criminal justice system works for everyone, regardless of their background or circumstance, to ensure that victims are treated with the utmost care and compassion.

And, when there are failings in justice, that everything possible is done to repair that damage.

8 Comments for Robert Halfon: “Too often, victims of crime in Harlow are treated abominably by the very apparatus meant to protect them, the criminal justice system”:

Victim
2022-06-16 08:44:07

Thats ironic, I emailed you regarding male domestic abuse and Essex police lack of action two weeks ago with no reply.

gary roberts
2022-06-16 09:18:10

What do you know about the criminal justice system in England and Wales, Mr. Halfon? "I do not necessarily blame the ministers " Why not? Your government has had 12 years to address any issues. Why did you cut legal aid, reduce police officers, prison officers, and probation officers. Cut our Magistrates court, lose neighbourhood policing and close many other criminal courts. Mr. Halfon start looking in the mirror before criticising the system of justice in this country!

Bobby Bobbler
2022-06-16 09:37:32

Robert, you should be in a position to do something about it. Start knocking on important doors and making noise for victims, and come up with a method to remove judges who are not doing their jobs, or state a minimum sentence so that judges don't get the choice.

David Forman
2022-06-16 11:02:09

Part privatisation of the Probation Service resulting from the 'Transforming Rehabilitation' White Paper in 2013 was a disaster. A series of damning reports by parliamentary committees and watchdogs found the restructure put public safety at risk and was “irredeemably flawed”. Privatisation meant private companies were invited to bid to become “probation delivery partners” for unpaid work and behavioural programmes, such as those for sex offenders and domestic abusers. However, these private companies contracts were terminated 14 months early in December 2020 and the work given back to the National Probation Service. This cock-up cost the taxpayer an extra £467 million. However, untold damage was done to rehabilitation of offenders. A Public Accounts Committee report published May 2019 said: "Mismanagement, risk taking and the lack of properly considered planning has badly let down offenders and there has been no noticeable improvement in the support offered to offenders since these reforms were first implemented, and they have failed to reduce reoffending by as much as expected, with the average number of reoffences committed by each reoffender actually increasing." See link to report: https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&url=https://publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm201719/cmselect/cmpubacc/1747/1747.pdf&ved=2ahUKEwjhqZW83rH4AhU1nVwKHQLbAYwQFnoECAQQAQ&usg=AOvVaw1zurvp6F8BibGLLwpUeFQa

Voteforme
2022-06-16 11:04:11

No argument with most of your comments although fortunately I have no direct experience of the circumstances you refer to. However I must take issue with "The Conservatives are the party of law and order". When our prime minister doesn't comply with the law and is at the centre of so many Covid rule breaking events, and when you support a man you do not trust, where is the leadership. How can you make such a statement. And the tory policies, as Gary Roberts, states have involved reducing the essence of law and order. And your own ethics advisor has resigned -"PM's former ethics adviser Lord Geidt says he quit after being placed in “impossible and odious” position over plan to risk breaking ministerial code"

David Forman
2022-06-16 11:13:34

The Offender Rehabilitation Bill arose out of the Transforming Rehabilitation White Paper which part privatised the Probation Service. Robert Halfon supported the Coalition Government's privatisation. He was absent from Parliament on a number of key votes, including the vote on providing money for the Bill on 11 November 2013. However, there is indisputable evidence Halfon voted against the Labour Party's amendments to the Bill: https://publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm201314/cmhansrd/cm140114/debtext/140114-0003.htm#14011496002514

David Vincent
2022-06-16 11:19:04

Bandwagon Bob Halfon is at it again, returning to the scene of his 'crime'. Halfon supported privatisation of the Probation Service which increased reoffending rates rather than reduce them and turned the supervision of released prisoners into a national disgrace.

Phil
2022-06-16 14:50:54

Far too often the rights of criminals is put above the rights of the general public. We have the right to be protected by those who are in positions of authority. Our children have the right to be protected against being attacked by other children who are violent - and in this case sexually violent. Personally I don't care if locking these people up will be bad for them in the long run. Just lock them up. I've found that people who have pressed the self-destruct button - be they drug addicts or alcoholics or recidivist criminals - will only alter their ways when they themselves have taken stock of their lives and the effect their behaviour has had and is having on themselves and others. Unfortunately no amount of talking or counselling will work for some, so punishment is the only other option. Loss of liberty IS an effective punishment but must be allowed to have the necessary effect. The person must be left alone to determine for themselves that what they have been doing is wrong. Today there are far too many agencies within our society that weaken the will of the human spirit rather than strengthening it. They offer emotional crutches and cotton-wool landing pads instead of allowing people to fall flat on their face with a big bump when it's required. Agencies who's ideologies have usurped our cultural remedies for dealing with problems such as anti-social behaviour and criminality. Pseudo-scientists putting a scientific spin on what they have hijacked and promoting themselves as the experts to cure all ills. They are to blame for a great deal of what's gone wrong in our society over the past 40 years or so.

Leave a Comment Below:

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *