National Youth Sector Census highlights uncertain finances for voluntary organisations despite delivering lions’ share of provision
Communities / Sun 17th Sep 2023 at 09:22am
NATIONAL Youth Sector Census highlights uncertain finances for voluntary organisations despite delivering lions’ share of provision.
The latest report from the National Youth Sector Census, managed by the National Youth Agency, shows that less than half (43%) of all youth work organisations in the East of England are operating in areas of deprivation. The data from the Census survey is correlated with Index of Multiple Deprivation (IMD) statistics to show how well the sector is responding to local demographic need. The latest cut of data suggests that there may be areas of deprivation where there is scant provision.
Nationally the report shows that shows that a fifth of youth work organisations have a waiting list of between three and six months and are struggling to meet demand. Despite undeniable need for these services, a quarter of voluntary sector organisations delivering youth work have less than six months’ of reserves.
The National Youth Agency has been tasked by the Department of Culture, Media and Sport to manage the Census and create a reliable dataset to help demonstrate the impact of youth work and improve the knowledge and insight for the youth sector and policy makers.
The report provides an analysis of the data received from 920 youth work organisations between March 2022 and April 2023, providing a snapshot of the Sector for the third time since the Census was launched in 2021. Of those youth work providers included in the data, 754 were from the Voluntary and Community Sector (CVS), 92 from Upper Tier Local Authorities (UTLAs) and 28 from district councils, metropolitan boroughs and unitary authorities.
The VCS continues to deliver the lion’s share of provision, primarily through a weekly youth club, but also through targeted activities such as physical and mental health support, and employment and training and activities to address violence and crime. The report also highlights that UTLAs are nearly three times as likely to prioritise activities designed to address exploitation as VCS organisations (92% compared to 31%). Whilst across the board, 84% of youth work organisations provide targeted activities to support mental health and wellbeing reflecting the growth in mental ill health amongst the younger generation highlighted in the latest NHS Digital data, which states that 18% of children aged 7 to 16 years and 22% of young people aged 17 to 24 years had a probable mental disorder.
The Census data is mapped against a range of other data, such as the Index of Multiple Deprivation showing the correlation between provision and the needs of communities. It highlights that whilst nationally, youth work appears to be meeting the needs of young people in deprived areas, some regions proportionally have more provision in deprived areas than others – for example in the North West, Yorkshire and the Humber, the North East and West Midlands.
The Census helps the National Youth Agency to map where youth work is taking place, as well as better understand the different ways in which it is being delivered and commissioned and where the sustainability of provision is at risk. Of the 59% of UTLAs providing direct delivery of open access youth provision, 64% are involved in contracting /commissioning and 51% provide infrastructure support, and just over half (51%) provide grant funding to youth providers.
Funding continues to be the hot potato of youth work with VCS organisations getting over half of their income (52%) from self-generated or trading income, compared to 35% for UTLAs. VCS organisations also report that they receive 61% of their income from a local authority grant or are commissioned to deliver a service and Some 81% receiving income from charitable donations, compared to only 14% of UTLAs.
About a third (35%) of VCS organisations report having reserves that would allow them to operate as normal for less than six months, a quarter (26%) have reserves of between six and 12 months, and one in five (21%) have reserves of over 12 months. More than one in 10 (14%) of organisations indicate that they do know how long their organisation would be able to operate for as normal with their current level of reserves.
Alex Stutz, Head of Knowledge, National Youth Agency, said: “The Census provides vital knowledge for those working in, commissioning and funding youth work. This snapshot report reinforces what we already know from our network – that the voluntary and community sector is carrying the can, delivering services with and for local authorities, but often they are operating within the context of an uncertain future, unable to plan from one year to the next.
“We know that there is some brilliant youth work taking place across the East of England, but we need an even more accurate a picture of youth work to better understand any shortfalls, as well as identify trends and really understand what kind of youth work is delivering the best outcomes.
“But we need an even more accurate a picture of youth work. It’s imperative that all those working with young people complete the Census, including those local authorities who weren’t included this time around, as well as youth workers funded by allied sectors, and small grassroots organisations, so we have the most accurate dataset to help inform commissioning and funding decisions.”
Other key findings from the Spring Snapshot report include:
On mean expenditure (average) last financial year was £443,000. Predicted expenditure is considerably higher for organisations operating in the most deprived areas, with average budgets highest in London (at £193,000) compared to £30,000 on average in the East Midlands.
The Census is located on the Youth Work One platform at www.youthworkone.org.uk The census is reported alongside an interactive dashboard which allows individuals to drill down into the census dataset in more detail. Youth Work One is a one stop shop for those working with young people, hosting guidance, resources and a forum to help youth workers improve their practice and network with their peers.
To read the National Youth Work Census: Snapshot, Spring 2023 report visit www.nya.org.uk/census-spring-snaps
Fair Play for Children draws attention to a key issue, that of the under-performance by Local Education Authorities (LEAs) to fulfil their legal obligations re children's and young people's recreation and leisure. These are set out in The Education Act 1996 (as amended by the Education & Training Act 1996), relevant paras are s508 and s507a (u13) and s507b (13+). A major issue is that they are not monitored, a deficiency in the Act (cf the 3-yeraly requirements re children's services in the 1989 Children Act). Additionally there is no analogue re central funding for adult recreation and leisure (eg Arts/Sports/Crafts Councils and more). Fair Play seeks amendments to the 1996 legislation which would ensure detailed accountability by LEAs. Fair Play is at http://www.fairplay31.online/index.html, and its analysis of s508etc is at http://www.fairplay31.epizy.com/pdf/1363944956.pdf. FPfC News runs in 4 sections, http://www.fairplay31.online/index.html#fpnews. Enquiries and contact alsways welcome